Categories
Clinical Modelling

Clinical Modelling – a primer

If you’re interested in how we organise, categorise and structure clinical information, a great place to start is Larry Weed’s 1971 lecture on problem-oriented medical records.

Larry may have been the first clinician to understand the challenges and to propose solutions. Almost half a century later, we are still grappling with them. Should a clinic letter from Breast Surgery be filed under “Surgery” or “Breast Surgery”? In other words, how should surgical specialties be sub-categorised?

When an anaesthetist encounters difficulty performing an epidural for a mother in labour, how should the details be recorded – what is the difference between an “attempt” and a “pass”? How should the concept of “guidance” be recorded – is loss-of-resistance part of the guidance element?

Questions of this nature are hard to answer – there will be a variety of views expressed by clinicians. When software engineers design, build, test and deploy software for the medical marketplace, they generally employ the services of clinicians to help tease out some of the thornier problems of relationships between different concepts in medicine. This process is sometimes called clinical curation, and happens over, and over, and over … again.

You might argue that what’s needed is a Clinical Terminology service such as SNOMED-CT. The trouble is, such a terminology will only get you so far. Sure, you now have access to about a hundred different concepts that relate to “blood pressure”, but when you’re building your application, how do you know which is the right concept for the context in which the blood pressure is being measured ?

This is where clinical models are essential. They capture not only the concept, whether it be coded in SNOMED-CT or some other terminology, but in addition, they show how the concept fits within the clinical context. The leading clinical modelling framework is OpenEHR. In future posts, I hope to demonstrate how OpenEHR models provide a clear path to application development, without the headaches and overhead of thrashing out relationships and semantic meaning in medicine.

The other framework that you may have heard of is HL7-FHIR. There is a lot of “lively” debate in the clinical modelling community of the relative merits of OpenEHR v HL7-FHIR. I’ve posted a few links below that will give you a flavour of the dialogue between the two communities.

If you’d like to get involved with the clinical modelling community, a good place to start is the OpenEHR discourse discussion forums. There is a good how to get started tutorial and also the introductory video from the 2017 OpenEHR day.

Links for more information:

By Grant Forrest

Director, Lunaria Ltd
Former NHS CCIO and Anaesthetist